MODSonline - MODSonline Polls, Is mapping modding?

Welcome Guest to MODSonline

Home | Forums | Register | Login

Main-Menu

Tutorials

Members-Online

lazygit	[Forum]
COLMAC	[Forum]
cobbspur	[Forum]
a.mk	[Downl]
joemax	[Tutor]

5 Members and 11 Guests

Chat MODSonline

0 People Now Chatting

MODSOnline TeamSpeak

download TeamSpeak

In-The-News

Monday, Dec. 1st
A message from foyleman
Sunday, Nov. 30th
MODSonair 156 Live
Friday, Nov. 28th
MODSonair Episode 155
Wednesday, Nov. 26th
MODSonair Forum Buttons
Monday, Nov. 24th
Holiday Gift Guide 2008 - PC

Latest Poll

Newsletter

Your Membership

User Name:
Password:
	Register.

In The Forums

FX help
CoD:WW Scripting.. Posts: (9) Views: (124) by COLMAC

A message from foyleman
In The News.. Posts: (8) Views: (76) by COLMAC

Weird texture problem
HL2 Level Design.. Posts: (5) Views: (30) by cz_squishy

Elevator Help
CoD 2 Level Desi.. Posts: (2) Views: (19) by luke0777

Google 468 Banner

Quake 4 Mods for Dummies

CoDWW Download

MODSonline Polls

List Categories • Back to General

Is mapping modding?	General
Posted on Tue. Sep. 12, 2006

A while ago, a discussion arose in which there was a difference of opinion - so we are going to pose it to you - the modsonline.com member to voice your opinion

Is mapping modding?
	Yes - mapping is a form of modding	34.09%
	No - modding is script and code based only	52.27%
	Thinking is hard	13.64%

Register to Add Comment

Most definitely	Tue. Sep. 12, 2006
In the literal sense - anything that alters the game from when it was sold off the shelf is a game modfification.
	by StrYdeR

	Tue. Sep. 12, 2006
mapping is mapping, modding is modding don't mix these 2.
	by Nemo06c

Yeah...	Tue. Sep. 12, 2006
I have to agree with Stryder. I think the confusion comes when mods are referred to as mods, but maps arn't called mods. Atleast in the general community of gamers.
	by supersword

	Tue. Sep. 12, 2006
No good mod without new maps so mapping is a part of modding imo EDIT: well atleast for bigger mods then
	by KilLjoY

	Tue. Sep. 12, 2006
what does it matter?
	by mwasley

	Tue. Sep. 12, 2006
Modding -> Modifying. I think you can talk about modding when you adapt an excisting file. When you create something from scratch its still called modding because it goes almost the same way. So in my opinion it's both modding, the second example I gave is just harder and made all by the modder him/herself.
	by Rammelslakje

	Tue. Sep. 12, 2006
i dont really think its 1 of both options: ill explain meself lol making a map is using new diffrent style and additions then instead of scipting or modding in both options it had actually nothing to do with acutally making a map with houses etc... you cant really make houses from a script you have to build it same goes with modding you can edit something or make with a modding programm your own shaped house but then again you still have to putt in ur map so that will conclude modding your own map... which aint a mod/script yet. ehhh... i hope you people understand because i have lost track in middle of story Darkthrone.
	by Darkthrone

	Tue. Sep. 12, 2006
Mapping is mapping, modding is modding cant say it another way
	by Sc00by22

	Tue. Sep. 12, 2006
hmm its a tricky one well if you say to somebody your modding, it always means your doing somthing like scripting or making a new compass or somthing. And if your mapping its always been classed as mapping... If your making a map you dont say "ye im making a really cool mod" or "talk to ya soon im off to do some modding" So modding is script based or making new pictures for huds n stuff Mapping is making a new level in a mapping program well thats my oppinion, lol!
	by Ricsta

	Tue. Sep. 12, 2006
maping is moding we are modifing the game by adding new maps for ppl to play with its just like mods we add new features for ppl to play with. same difference so mapping is modding :D
	by sevensniff

	Tue. Sep. 12, 2006
I think its fine to consider mapping and modding all part of a modding comunity, but the difference between modders and mappers does clear up confusion into what they specifically do
	by Raaaaa

	Wed. Sep. 13, 2006
when your creating a bran new game you are not modifying nothing. There for things are broke down into coders, skinners, modellers, mappers Modding is just a word used to describe your a person that is modifying somthing, could be anything, dont even need to have anything to do with computers. a mapper is a mapper, a coder is a coder, a skinner is a skinner I think ya get the point now, lol
	by Ricsta

Comments are right.. what is this vote?	Wed. Sep. 13, 2006
Most of the comments tend to agree that mapping is a form of modding. This is just as scripting, coding, skinning, etc. are also all forms of modding. Modding is a general term defined as the act of modifying. Anything that changes a game from its original state is a form of modification. Maps that don't come with a game are therefore modifications for that game. Just because it's in addition to the game doesn't mean it doesn't change it from the original form. Back to my comment title... How is it that most of the comments here agree that mapping is a form of modding yet the scoring (at this time) reveals that most people think mapping and modding are unrelated?
	by foyleman

levels -> maps -> mods -> TC's -> Expansions	Thu. Sep. 14, 2006
I always considered mapping to be level-editing (taken from the earliest days of Wolfenstein3D that's really what it was). My personal view, if you change the theme, goals, and/or gameplay significantly then it becomes a mod. IMHO ;) You have to change the way the game plays for it to become a mod. For example, in the pre-commercial days, Red Orchestra was a Mod for UT2K4. (In fact it became a TC - total conversion, but the term doesn't seem to be used any more) It significantly changed the gameplay, the scenarios, the rules etc. However you were still able to create maps (levels) for the game. In this case I would have said you were mapping for the RO Mod and not modding for the RO mod. DoDPro is an example mod for DoD Source. Here, the gameplay has been changed at an engine level. The ballastics have changed, the recoil of weapons, sprinting etc ... It still uses the same dod source maps (level) though. There is still a difference between the mod itself and the levels that it uses. There always seemed a pretty distinct difference simply mapping and modding. However the borders seem to be merging. There is a "mod" for DoomIII called Classic Doom. (check it out on moddb if you are a Doom fan, it is a must-have). The team took the original level design from the original Doom but used the textures, prefabs, and monsters from DoomIII. There was a little artistic licence here and there, but you would recognise the layout immediately. Of course, this all ran on the DoomIII engine. The thing is, the levels together formed a scenario or story. Strictly speaking they were just (sic) levels but together they formed a complete package. They didn't tweak the engine, they didn't change the gameplay, they just made new levels. But all the levels together seemed to constitute a Mod. Strictly speaking it was just a map-pack for DoomIII, although, most in the community would consider this a mod. Now, if you read the last sentences again, you might realise that a certain company did the same thing commercially. Id software released RoE for DoomIII. Technically it was the same thing; new levels, a few new models, but no change to the gameplay or engine driving the game. Int the commercial world this wasn't considered level-editing, or modding. This was considered an expansion. Funny thing is .. if a company releases a commercial package, it is considered an expansion. And if the community release the same package it is considered a Mod. So now the question is when we create maps and levels, are we really modding or just creating Expansions?
	by Gaspode

yup	Thu. Sep. 14, 2006
I go with StrYdeR, editing w/e from a game is called modding IMO. Grtz
	by r0el

	Thu. Sep. 14, 2006
My opinion they are seperate. They are both equal talents. One is affecting the players movement and one is affecting the visual environment.
	by {UST}Juice

it's both	Thu. Sep. 14, 2006
mapping is both mapping and modding. When you create a map, it is just that...mapping. but when you go and add scripts to make doors work and you modify bat files for mapping, that is modding. So you would have to say that it's both mapping and modding. But i don't think that the two should be combined. They do need seperate definitions
	by cybershot

	Fri. Sep. 15, 2006
Honestly, any form of creating or adding something new to a game is MODing/ifying. You can't make a new completley different mod without any maps. Every form of adding/changing is a form of modding, including coding, modeling, mapping, animation/skinning(though ties in with modeling), sounds, ect..
	by Dwahlst

	Sun. Sep. 17, 2006
I take the view that it is a little more complicated than it first seems. A map like "Second Coming" (which I like), I wouldn't consider modding - it does nothing new or different to the game. A map like "Island Madness 2" (If you haven't got it then you REALLY should) adds new features (Stargate, ring transporters etc) and HEAPS of scriptable objects, I would consider a mod.
	by general99

No...	Sun. Sep. 17, 2006
Mapping is creating a map to play on from scratch. Modding is editing something to look different, play different, etc.
	by Bob_The_Reclaimer

	Sat. Sep. 23, 2006
Aslong as the map brings atleast a new idea/scenario/location etc to the game - then yes mapping is modding edit// Otherwise if you modify a stock map like Newvillers....are you not changing it through mapping.... modding means MODIFYING - changing something - If you map, you ARE changing the game.
	by techno2sl

Mapping is modding	Sun. Sep. 24, 2006
There are ways to mod inside a map without changing the vaniila mod. SO in my case modding and mapping goes together.
	by Larven

	Mon. Sep. 25, 2006
From Wikipedia: Mod or modification is a term generally applied to computer games, especially first-person shooters and real-time strategy games. Mods are made by the general public, and can be entirely new games in themselves. They can include new items, weapons, characters, enemies, models, modes, textures, levels, story lines and gamemodes. They also usually take place in unique locations. They can be single-player or multiplayer. Mods that add new content to the underlying game are often called partial conversions, while mods that create an entirely new game are called total conversions. ----- This should explain it. Mapping is modding
	by genuvine

Mapping=Mapping	Tue. Sep. 26, 2006
Agree with Nemo06c!!! Mapping is Mapping ^^
	by coltfinger

	Tue. Sep. 26, 2006
Modding is editing script to provide specific game preformance from the modder (ie. making a weapon do more damage) Mapping is simply designing a map. What people might confuse is a CONVERSION, which includes both elements.
	by Firebomb

Credit Cards | Remortgages | Problem Mortgage | Property for sale in Spain | Mortgage

All logos and trademarks and information in this site are property of MODSonline LLC © 2008.
The comments are property of their posters.

RSS news feeds for MODSonline can be found News.php.

MODSonline Subscriptions

Partners

The Firing Box

CODAddicts - Call of Duty News & Downloads

Frag Universe

XoXide

Call of Duty Headquarters

Battle for Europe COD2

modbase.be

Ask About
Advertising

Friends

The Clan Database

SOF2 Files and Downloads

ModTheater

Ask About
Advertising

Link to Us

468 x 60

468 x 60

468 x 60

150 x 400

140 x 40

Advertise
With Us

MODSonair

View in iTunes

Please help us to raise in the ranks of podcasting and subscribe to our itunes feed using the link above.

MODSonair Releases

• MODSonair Episode 155
• MODSonair Episode 154
• MODSonair Episode 153
• MODSonair Episode 152
• MODSonair Episode 151

Next Show

The next MODSonair show will air LIVE on:

Time remaining:

Copyright © 2008 MODSonline
Tresware Content Management System Copyright © 2008 Tresware

Website Designed and Hosted